Comentário ao Leaf no New York Post. Deplorável :(

Discussão geral sobre a Mobilidade Elétrica e notícias
Responder
Avatar do Utilizador
ruimegas
Gestor do Forum
Mensagens: 5076
Registado: 04 jan 2011, 23:39
Data de fabrico: 09 jun 2011
Capacidade bateria: 59 Ah 12 barras
Localização: Oeiras
Contacto:

Comentário ao Leaf no New York Post. Deplorável :(

Mensagem por ruimegas » 04 abr 2011, 15:58

Comentário ao Leaf no New York Post. Deplorável :(. (Future? No, a fig Leaf)

É por estas e por outras que por vezes os "velhos do Restelo" vão sobrevivendo :evil: . Mas começamos a sentir o nervosismo que estes inergúmenos "petrolheads" com o aumento das vendas dos VE's pelo mundo :twisted: :twisted: .
Imagem
The Nissan Leaf has just arrived in New York City. It’s a real breakthrough for anyone who was getting tired of all the old synonyms for failure.

"The new all-electric Leaf, which (in theory) is powered by plugging it into an ordinary outlet, is going to make Ryan Leaf look like a success story.
Nissan’s Leaf isn’t as flawed and ridiculous as the Edsel. It’s far worse.
The 1958 Edsel, ugly and mediocre as it was, with its vertical slash like a gaping wound symbolizing all the red ink that gushed onto Ford’s balance sheet, became a laughingstock not because it was so far out of the ordinary, but because the public had been whipped into expecting the extraordinary.
But at least only Ford lost money on the Edsel. We’re all losing money on the Nissan Leaf, thanks to the taxpayer subsidies that willed it into the marketplace. Each time you see one of these glorified golf carts flit by, you should be thinking: There goes $7,500 of my money.
The Leaf’s range is a joke — early reviewers have been startled to notice the gauge of a fully charged car warning that it expects to go only about 65 miles, a bit shy of Nissan’s claims last year of a 138-mile range.
One owner complained that the real range is only 50 miles.
Moreover, the gauge isn’t reliable. Here I take pleasure at introducing a delightful new usage: “to turtle.”
Drivers have been saying on online forums that when the gauge tells them they’ve still got five or 10 or 15 miles of juice left, the vehicle instead goes dead.
But first comes a really cute warning sign of an orange turtle icon to symbolize the battery’s tragically slow-moving death crawl. You thought you were in a car, but suddenly you’re driving a turtle. A few minutes after that, you’re not driving at all. You’re sitting in a paperweight.
Leaf lovers have been boasting that the car goes zero to 60 quite nicely. Unfortunately it goes 60 to zero with even more breathtaking alacrity.
Feel pretty secure about taking this baby out on the highway? Like I said: golf cart.
But don’t worry: Nissan has promised to cover your towing fees if the car turtles out on you. They won’t be compensating you for the pain and suffering of enduring the wrecker crew snickering at you and your precious little wind-up automobile. (One Leaf driver who turtled was asked by a mechanic why he couldn’t just get a jump start.)
At 300 W. 57th St., Popular Mechanics has installed what seems to be the first Leaf-charging station in the city. The cost? Over $2,000. But PM’s home is a major commercial building. Your house probably isn’t, so it won’t be able to handle that kind of an outlet without a costly upgrade of the electrical system. You’ll also need a special permit and inspection.
Hey, wait — the Leaf is supposed to run on ordinary household current, right? That means it’s useless for most apartment dwellers (go ahead, ask your landlord if you can run an extension cord to the building’s power supply) but fine for suburbanites. Only those suburbanites who have a lot of time on their hands, though: a PM test driver said it took 34 hours to recharge his Leaf using ordinary 120-volt household power. “For most people,” the gearhead magazine sheepishly noted, “the time constraint might preclude using the Leaf for everyday commuting.”
Ya think? A vehicle that takes a day and a half to charge can’t be used every day? Wasn’t the whole purpose of the Leaf supposed to be short everyday commuting? What good is it if you can only use it Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays? The Leaf’s failures recall an old joke people used to tell about the Jaguar in the ’70s: If you want a Jag, you need three of them — one in the shop, one for parts, one to drive.
The Leaf, the clean, green vehicle, which even with the subsidy costs over $25,000, isn’t powered by that nasty carbon-packed fossil fuel gasoline. Nope — it’s most likely powered by coal, which is what supplies about half of the power stations where households get electricity.
President Obama is not in the habit of admitting to being wrong about anything, and in his Wednesday energy speech he solemnly reaffirmed his utter devotion to wishful thinking and naivety, promising the federal government would buy only alternative-fuel automobiles by 2015.
The US has about as much chance of becoming “energy-independent” this century as the earth has of becoming independent of the sun. And the Honda Civic-sized smugmobile the Nissan Leaf — powered by coal, corporate welfare and a regressive taxation scheme that takes from everyone but benefits only those who can afford to drop over $25,000 on a toy slash personality statement — is to 21st century economics what the Edsel was to 1950s aesthetics."

Em: http://m.nypost.com/f/mobile/news/opini ... BZlqOGNtYL
NISSAN LEAF Branco c/Spoiler mk1 de 09JUN2011. 195.000 kms.
TESLA Model 3 AWD. Encomenda 03JUL2019. Entrega 09JUL2019. 72078 kms.
Associado da Associação de Utilizadores Veículos Eléctricos http://www.uve.pt

Essiemme
Proprietário Leaf
Mensagens: 1599
Registado: 08 jan 2011, 11:46
Data de fabrico: 01 jan 2011
Capacidade bateria: +/- 64,69Ah 12Barras
Localização: Porto Alto, Portugal

Re: Comentário ao Leaf no New York Post. Deplorável :(

Mensagem por Essiemme » 04 abr 2011, 16:33

Se toda a gente gostasse do Vermelho, o que seria do Amarelo ?

Que grande palhaço, o sr que escreveu esta crítica...

:x
11 Barras.
+ de 222.800 KMs
+/- 84,55 SOH :|

Avatar do Utilizador
mjr
Administrador do site
Mensagens: 9926
Registado: 04 jan 2011, 15:55
Data de fabrico: 30 mai 2018
Capacidade bateria: 114.8 Ah 12 barras
Localização: Porto

Re: Comentário ao Leaf no New York Post. Deplorável :(

Mensagem por mjr » 04 abr 2011, 16:48

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

É tão extrema a "opinião" que até parece irreal.
Nissan Leaf 40 Tekna preto, entregue em 30 de maio de 2018. 51400km em 2024-02-15
Nissan LEAF mk1 Preto, entregue em 7 de julho de 2011. 180000 km em 2023-12-22.
Tesla Model 3 LR preto entregue em 2019-03-06. 125000 km em 2023-12-22.
Sócio da associação de Utilizadores de Veículos Elétricos, UVE: http://www.uve.pt

Avatar do Utilizador
mikexilva
Moderador Global
Mensagens: 1493
Registado: 06 jan 2011, 00:44
Data de fabrico: 01 jan 2011
Capacidade bateria: Metade dos 24Kwh
Contacto:

Re: Comentário ao Leaf no New York Post. Deplorável :(

Mensagem por mikexilva » 04 abr 2011, 17:19

Às vezes quem escreve estes artigos não tem noção da realidade e da força que existe nas tendências no mundo. Tendo em conta que o LEAF foi eleito carro do ano na Europa, só fica mal a quem escreve estas coisas, principalmente se o LEAF for eleito carro do ano mundial.

No meu ver uma tecnologia emergente tem que analisada do ponto de vista do seu potencial de forma a imaginarmos num futuro próximo, proporcionando as melhores condições, o que espera da tecnologia, e não o contrario, que como escrevem no artigo, procuraram reunir as piores condições e as piores situações.
Por exemplo quem é que no seu perfeito juízo vai comprar um LEAF para o carregar em 120V em casas alheias e quer andar todos os dias 160Km? mas de qq forma esta critica não se enquadra na Europa, pois deve ser muito difícil encontrar alguma casa com 120V.
Estes Srs não o elegeram carro do ano, e querem melhorar esta critica? melhorem primeiro a rede eléctrica.

Avatar do Utilizador
Filipe
Proprietário Leaf
Mensagens: 3088
Registado: 19 fev 2011, 03:51
Data de fabrico: 09 mai 2011
Capacidade bateria: 51,50 Ah - 10 Barras
Localização: Murtal - Parede - Lisboa

Re: Comentário ao Leaf no New York Post. Deplorável :(

Mensagem por Filipe » 04 abr 2011, 17:56

Bem Dito, primeiro instalem no país uma rede de distribuição eléctrica que pelo menos seja do Século XX ( Já não digo Século XXI, porque são
capaz de não ter dinheiro suficiente para isso ) :!:
Nissan LEAF mk1 - Cinzento-Prateado - 86,5 K em 29 Jul 2018.
Nissan LEAF 3.0 +e - Cinzento Diamante - 22 Nov 2019

Responder

Voltar para “Página principal de Discussão e Notícias”